Tuesday, November 17, 2026

S.S.Van Dine : The Dragon Murder Case, 1933

 


 

 

It is a miracle that I am alive. I thank God for saving me—and, through Him, the doctors in charge of the Intensive Cardiologic Care Unit  and the University Cardiology Department at the General Hospital di Bari. When my son brought my bag of personal belongings into the small ICCU room—where I was waiting to be connected to the medical equipment—he mentioned that he had included a few books, in case I felt like reading. I had already begun rereading S.S. Van Dine’s The Dragon Murder Case at home—using the new translation recently prepared for the publisher Polillo—and this gave me the perfect opportunity to finish it.

In terms of publication order, The Dragon Murder Case was Van Dine’s seventh novel, and the fourth to feature an "impossible crime" within its plot.

In this seventh mystery of the series, the atmosphere is bizarre, with a touch of the gothic. The solution—which is truly ingenious—hinges on clues that are placed in plain sight, yet whose significance is difficult to discern, as they seem to vanish into the very scene being presented. Naturally, it falls to Philo Vance to decipher their true meaning.

Over the course of two days—between August 11th and 13th, during one of the hottest New York summers on record—two crimes occur, plunging an entire family and their guests into utter confusion. The first involves Sanford Montague, who dives into the "Dragon Pond"—a name given to the site by the Native American tribes of Inwood—only to vanish completely, never resurfacing. Those present at the time of the dive—or who otherwise witnessed it—included his fiancée, Bernice Stamm, and her brother Rudolf, an ichthyologist who collects and breeds tropical fish; a close family friend, Gale Leland; Rudolf Stamm’s stockbroker, Alex Greef; a dandy named Kirwin Tatum; a middle-aged widow, Teeny McAdam; and the actress Ruby Steele. Also in the house were Matilda, the Stamm matriarch; Trainor, the manservant; Dr. Holliday, the family physician; and Mrs. Schwarz, a nurse attending to Matilda.

Leland, Greef, and Tatum dive in after him, but to no avail—they find nothing; Montague has vanished into thin air.

At this point, Leland calls the police, and Markham invites Philo Vance to accompany him to the Stamm residence, hoping he might be able to get to the bottom of this impossible disappearance.

After questioning those present, Philo Vance realizes that nearly everyone had a reason to loathe the man. His fiancée, Bernice, had doubts about his fidelity—a note found in a jacket hanging in her bedroom closet suggests he was planning to meet another woman. Rudolf Stamm had come to realize that Montague was merely an adventurer, more interested in the family fortune than in his sister. He was also disliked by Greef and Tatum, and some of the female guests had encountered him previously in his capacity as a gigolo. But how could he have vanished? Is he dead, or...? The police systematically search the grounds surrounding the villa, but to no avail. Consequently, Vance—assisted by Van Dine, District Attorney Markham, and Sergeant Heath—waits for the pond to be drained via a conduit. And what do they find in the end? Nothing but mud. And in the mud, the imprint of a three-toed, clawed creature—a dragon?

This is what Mrs. Matilde Stamm obsessively claims: that the dragon, the long-time guardian of the Stamm family, has abducted and killed the man who sought to disturb their peace. From its lair—presumably located within natural cavities dating back to the last ice age—the dragon keeps watch over the living members of the Stamm family, as well as the dead who rest in a funeral chapel not far from the house. Indeed, the chapel—and the dead who lie there, lending a gothic touch to the tale—is one of the settings where a crime took place; the second one, in fact. For Greef, who in the two days that followed had argued with both Tatum and Stamm, also vanished—only to be discovered in the same spot where poor Montague (or what remained of him) had been found. The body was already in a state of rigor mortis, bearing various fractures—including one to the skull—as well as signs of strangulation and horrific wounds that suggested the claws of a dragon. When Greef was discovered—in that same glacial pothole—he bore identical injuries: fractures, abrasions, a deep, fatal wound to the skull, and three ghastly gashes across his chest, as if left by a dragon’s claws.

Naturally, the dragon exists only because everyone believes in its existence; as Vance puts it: "Markham, we're dealing not only with cold-blooded practical facts, but with a sinister superstition; and we cannot afford to ignore either one."

The situation appears hopelessly tangled, yet Vance gradually manages to unravel the mystery. He identifies the culprit, who subsequently dies in an accident—an event immediately followed by the elderly Mrs. Stamm suffering a fatal heart attack.

 

 

 

This seventh novel is an absolute gem. Vance is in fine form, offering the reader a chance to delve into his encyclopedic knowledge—first regarding dragons, and later, tropical fish. The former are explored in a dedicated dissertation in Chapter XIV, centered on the idea that if an entire community believes in something legendary, they end up making it real—at least for themselves. The latter are the subject of an erudite discourse in Chapter XVIII, which provides Vance with the key insight that ultimately leads to solving the first murder. Furthermore, just as Vance had previously identified the site of the second murder within the mortuary chapel—by discovering a gardenia that had been in Greef’s lapel—he later returns to the chapel, and even opens the coffin of the first Stamm ancestor, to uncover how the first murder was carried out.

This novel differs from its predecessors; for one thing, it features a more pronounced Gothic atmosphere than any of the others, and the situations it presents are, to say the least, bizarre. In the eyes of the conventional and rigid Markham, Vance appears to have lost his wits when he begins talking about dragons—yet, this discussion leads to a crucial realization. The same occurs when Vance holds forth on tropical fish: Markham huffs and yawns, dismissing it as yet another eccentric outburst from two men obsessed with such creatures (Rudolf Stamm and Philo Vance). And yet, it is precisely the fish—specifically the "dragon fish," hideous-looking specimens that dwell in the ocean depths—that provide Vance with the thread he needs to unravel the mystery. Of the two dissertations, the second bears a striking resemblance to another one Vance delivers in the novel preceding The Kennel Murder Case—specifically, the one concerning dogs. However, there is a notable difference compared to the way J.D. Carr employs such digressions. When Carr includes a dissertation—the famous "Locked Room Lecture" being a prime example—it serves solely to establish atmosphere. Beyond that, it serves no further purpose; the "Locked Room Lecture" functions as a standalone chapter with no bearing on the solution to The Three Coffins (much like the "Locked Room Lecture" by Rawson in Death from a Top Hat, which is similarly detached from the resolution). The same applies to the dissertations on clocks and the Spanish Inquisition in Death Watch—found in Chapter 13 ("The Skull-Watch"), Chapter 7 ("The Noise of a Chain"), and Chapter 20 ("A Letter Under the Floor")—which ultimately contribute absolutely nothing to the final solution. In contrast, with S.S. Van Dine, a dissertation is never merely an end in itself; while it may appear to be, it actually serves to clarify a point that has escaped Markham’s notice. Philo Vance—with his—to some, insufferable—tendency to parade his encyclopedic knowledge (ranging from quoting Latin verse—Forsan et haec olim meminisse iuvabit from Virgil’s Aeneid: "perhaps one day it will be a pleasure to remember these things"—to translating fragments of Menander, a detail that links this novel to The Bishop Murder Case, or discussing everything from dogs to tropical fish)—is, in a certain sense, more "real" than the pompous Dr. Fell. It should also be noted that this is the first "locked-room" novel set in a swimming pool—a scenario that some believe was first explored by Carr in a novel featuring Merrivale, namely A Graveyard to Let.  

Moreover, unlike conventional investigators, Vance does not hesitate to break the rules to achieve his goal—even if it means disturbing the sleep of the dead to uncover the truth. Once again, he clashes with the narrow-minded, self-righteous attitude of Markham, who is obsessed with what is and isn't permitted: "You can't do that, Vance!" he protested. "You can't break into a private coffin this way. You can be held legally accountable. . . ." "This is no time for technicalities, Markham" (Chapter 20). In the end, however, Vance prevails, proving to Markham that the contents of a coffin can tip the scales. I specify Markham rather than Heath, as the latter has already grasped what they will find inside the century-old casket. This tendency of Vance’s to flout the rules is also elevated to a higher level in an earlier novel, The Scarab Murder Case, in which Vance appears closer to Poirot than one might initially assume. While it is often thought that Agatha Christie introduced a more extreme approach to confronting a criminal through Poirot during the Second World War, Vance’s behavior is just as radical—and it is worth noting that this was conceived as early as 1930.

The solution to this novel is absolutely brilliant, and the book is, quite rightly, one of Van Dine’s best.

The novel’s settings are not entirely fictional: the epilogue in the final chapter mentions that the Stamm residence was demolished and the land confiscated by the City of New York; nothing of the house remains today. A friend of mine overseas, Mike Grost, adds that "the wild forest area where the novel transpires is now Inwood Hill Park, run by New York City." The actual park still contains the foundation of the now-demolished Straus mansion—the 19th-century country home of a millionaire family who perished aboard the Titanic in 1912. Similarly, *The Dragon Murder Case* is set at the fictional Stamm mansion; an epilogue at the end of the novel reveals that the mansion has been torn down, leaving only its foundation behind. I do not know whether the "Dragon Pool" also has a real-life counterpart".

In other words, the setting of the story—a wild, wooded area containing a small pond—corresponds to what is now Inwood Hill Park, managed by the City of New York. Furthermore, the park still holds the ruins and foundations of the grand Straus estate—a family of millionaires who died in the 1912 Titanic disaster. It is possible, then, that Van Dine based his story on actual remains that had been abandoned since 1912. To put it another way, the standard disclaimer found in almost all works of fiction—that "any resemblance to actual persons, places, or events is purely coincidental"—does not strictly apply here.

In this instance, it would seem that the resemblance is not coincidental at all. 

Pietro De Palma 

No comments:

Post a Comment