Thursday, December 21, 2023

Hake Talbot : The Hangman’s Handyman, 1942


One of the best Locked Rooms ever 

Even from the first lines we see projected on a remote island, battered by gales, which has a name that says it allKrakenlike the mythological monster of the deep seaAnd the atmosphere already expresses its first signs ofstrange and threatening.

Nancy Garwoodactress and showgirlis found lying across the bottom of the bed, still wearing the evening dress and and then she doesn’t how she arrived  to be in bed. She remembers when she arrived in the afternoon along with Jackson Frant and dinner: as yousay later, she knew Frant “intimately perhaps” but certainly notgood .. (it means that he had sex with himbut as a person he knewlittle)Also remembers the heavy atmosphere of that house and palpableservantssilent and without an identity as  if they were shadowsthe strange and the guests seated around the table, eight including the host and five empty seats to form thirteen places, omen of doomShe remembers the salt dropped in error on the tablecloth, she remembers the broken mirror, remembers thefrightened facesShe doesn’t remember anything.

When Nancy falls in the living roomby candlelight, the clock strikes ten o’clock p.m.. She remembers that she was at dinner at nineMust have been unconscious at least one hourThe guests should be thereplaying the piano, playing cards .. Insteadthere is none.
Nancy increasingly tensethe show turns to the dark and threateningby candlelight.
We observe the sceneHake Talbotwith consummate skill we would like to say (but this is the debutintroduces the story as if it were not a detective novel, but a fantastic novel, a gothic novel : it would seem one of Radcliffe or WalpoleThe candlelightinstead of decreasing the voltagefor the darkit increases it, because it illuminates what is directly in frontbut leaves the rest in darknessAnd while Nancy advances frightenedscared and tensethe sound here is powerful and unexpected: someone knocks at the door.
She goes to openbecause not even the servants made himas if the house was emptyand she founds Roger Kincaida professional playerwith an ambiguous pastbut who knows human nature better than othersand above all knows how to go down to things, even to those who apparently are not seen.
Talbot reserves entrance leading to Kincaidwith which we can understand that we are facing thedeus ex machina” of the situation.
The nature of the character is also entrusted with the clothes she wearsa heavy raincoat and ahat from the wide brimwhich remind us instantly (at least on those familiar with the detective genrethe most famous character of Carr, the Dr. FellIt way as any to tell the readerit is the investigatorthere are the typical conditions of carrian novels, that are impossible crimes or closed chambers.
The impossible crime is what distinguishes the novel, and is also the event that caused the amnesia of the girl.

Nancy recalls that the number of thirteen invited (but a family of four was not reachedhad provided an opportunity for Jackson Frant, industrial chemicals, could make fun of her brotherLord Evan Tethryn enormously superstitious.
The mockery that was continued in a crescendo of tension, before reading an ancient documentwhich indicated an unspeakable family secretthat the brother had thrown into the fire, then causing the breaking of a mirror, powder, and then causing the deposit of salt on tableclothand at the same time emphasizing the ensuing seven years of troubleThe effect of this series of eventsis the curse cast by Evan at Jackthe real secret unspeakableto kill the recipient immediately,and let him rot in a short time.
So did the exasperated Lord Evan against the brother Jack FrantAnd hearing the curse  Od rot you!” Jack was struck by lightning felldead: apparently Od, the sea goddess whom Evan had turnedwas briskly to oblige. The body was then transported to his room and left there.
But we have before pointed to a crime impossible: what ever it would be impossible in instant death as surely falling into a pure coincidence, a man cursed by his half-brotherIt could very well be a heart attackSo far nothing indicates manifest impossibilitythere is only a coincidencealso if strangeThe impossibility instead will be realized before our eyes, when Kincaid will travel to see the corpsewhose memory causes fainting again of Nancy. While Kincaid her aidsa new character materializesArnold Makepeace.

I note that the expedient of heightened tension, we have already seen both in the wake of Nancy (who finds herself in a strange house and darkness), and in the verbal confrontation between the two half-brothers, reappears now in the brief dialogue between these two characters: Arnold if at words he confirms as told by Nancy and tries to be as objective as possible, speaks almost shouting, in a tone that suggests to Rogan, as his partner is terrified.

Well, he obviously present in the stroke, he is hoped in his heart that even Dr. Braxton defines it such. And the tension grows, and continues when the first Rogan rummaging through the ashes of the fireplace, he founds almost intact the loot of pages that had been thrown on the fire (which is a series of reports showing old black magic powers given to the family of two brothers by Od, an elemental spirit of sea) and then when he himself, in the library, founds a series of books specifically occult character, read and reread, especially one with such a famous short story by Edgar Allan Poe: The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar. Do you remember that case? No? It talks about the mesmerism, animal magnetism made in the case of a man at death, which remains in a state of suspended death, until awakened from this state of decomposition in a heartbeat. Because Talbot refers precisely to this story by Poe? Why Kincaid will find Frant, wearing the dress evening, died not from a few hours, but died at least a month, in decomposition so advanced that the only way to assign him the identity, it’s a ring that could not have been imbedded after died.
Here is the manifest impossibility that would legitimize a supernatural intervention, to Od.
That’s it?
No. Someone tries to kill Kincaid strangling and yet manages to leave the room leaving her locked inside, with mosquito nets and intact old-growth, impossible to disassemble and assemble outside. Carr would say vanished into air.  Only Od in person could have been!
But why Od would want to kill Kincaid?
Nothing I will say more, except  that the ending of novel is amazing.

Why the novel did impress me so favorably?
The first, we are dealing with a crime so impossible that it can not be more impossible, and even a beautiful Locked Room. Talbot, in short, to create his debut novel, in honor of Carr and Rawson, and fills it impossible crimes and locked rooms, in a supernatural tricks illusions (the same Hake Talbot dabbled in magic) and centers the target , expecting to an established pattern of classic mystery (island battered by storm, secluded villa, curse, crime impossible and even more in a closed chamber, substitutions in person, continuous plot reversals) and creating an atmosphere dense and palpable able to fascinate.
Also it wouldn’t seem to be a debut. It has not flaws in the final by Rim of the Pit, though a lot of persons still consider it superior to ours. The fact is that the ending can not hold the tension accumulated up to that point and Rim of the Pit seems to be missing something, because, summingimpossibilitytoimpossibility, and concentrating the explanation of all the mysteries in the finale, “with an effect of complexity a bit too exhausting”, as would tell someone I know, Talbot can not answer all the questions, to satisfy them completely, and leaving a sense of something unresolved.
This leads us to consider how, instead, the first novel, with some humility that is lacking in the second hand, tends to solve the puzzles, each time, leaving only the final identification of the murderer (which is not easy). In fact, the first Talbot/Kincaid addresses the Locked Room, and then he explains the crime impossible.
Beyond this there are similarities between the two novels.
First, the mythological allusions: here is an elemental deities, Od, a demon of the deep sea while there another demon is, an Indian demon, a Windingo. In addition both novels, show magic tricks performed and explained by the guests.
Here and there you notice any mistakes, you may notice that only after reading the novel several times: first it says that an examination of the fingers of the corpse decomposed by Kincaid, Sergeant Dorsey, the police photographer and Feldman Medical Examiner Dr. Murchison, we note that had been removed the skin of the fingertips; then at the end of the novel, we read that the corpse was that of Frant because Feldmann had taken fingerprints: inconsistency perhaps be explained by a previous draft of the novel different?
Beyond this, even Talbot, as Halter, may have used, to wrap the plot of his novel, a series of references to him earlier: the guests present at a villa on an island, reminiscent of And Then There Were None 1939, by Agatha Christie; the 13 dinner guests, another novel by previous Christie, Lord Edgware Dies, 1933; and finally, I would be even tempted to believe that the same misfortune Rogan on board the vessel in the middle stormy sea and its landing on the island where the other guests are waiting, could refer to Careless Corpse, 1937, by King Charles Daly.
Well … an extraordinary novel, which takes engrossed until the last page.

Pietro De Palma

P. S.
The device by Talbot, also was used by Bill Pronzini and  Paul Halter.