An analysys with spoilers of The Canary Murder Case by S.S. Van Dine
The Canary Murder Case is one of the finest
detective novels from the Golden Age of crime fiction.
By the time he wrote it,
Willard Huntington Wright had already published The Benson Murder Case
(1926), a novel that had achieved considerable success. Yet, it was undoubtedly
with The Canary Murder Case (1927) and subsequently The Greene Murder
Case (1928) that he established himself as the preeminent author of his
era—two novels that set the standard for the genre.
It is worth noting that they
are antithetical: while The Greene Murder Case is a tale of death
unfolding claustrophobically within a mansion—where the heirs to a fortune are
compelled to live, and where a heavy, leaden atmosphere lingers from the first
moment to the last—The Canary Murder Case presents an atmosphere that
is, by contrast, frivolous and sophisticated, far lighter in tone, yet no less
complex.
Together, these three novels
form an ideal trilogy.
In my view, one could argue
that this is among the greatest detective novels ever conceived. Today, given
that the solutions devised by Van Dine have been adopted—and subsequently
surpassed—by many great writers who followed him, he might appear somewhat
diminutive, like Tom Thumb; to some, his plot resolutions might even seem
laughable. And yet, one cannot consider the detective fiction of the 1930s
without bowing reverentially before Van Dine. For without him, there would have
been no Ellery Queen, no Charles Daly King, and no early Rex Stout.
Among Van Dine’s works, it was
precisely The Canary Murder Case and The Greene Murder Case that
exerted the greatest influence on those who came after him. The Canary
Murder Case, in particular, had a disruptive impact at the time: it topped
the bestseller lists for several months.
Julian Symons in his most famous critical work,
Bloody Murder, reported the opinion of another critic, Howard Haycraft, writing
that “ ..his second book, The Canary Murder Case
1927, broke all modern publishing records for detective fiction at the time” (Julian Symons, Bloody Murder, Penguin Books, 1985,
page 101).
Further on, to testify to the huge success achieved
by this novel and the following novel, which upset the detective literature of
the time, dominated by British authors, Symons stated that “It was said that
he had lifted the detective story on to the plane of a fine art, and by his own
account he was the favorite crime writer of two Presidents” (op. cit. pag.
102).
But why was The Canary Murder
Case such a success? Let’s examine the
story.
First of
all, who is the "Canary"? To borrow the very prose of Willard
Huntington Wright— Margaret Odell had
received the sobriquet of Canary as a result of a part
she had played in an
elaborate ornithological ballet of the Follies, in which
each girl had been
gowned to represent a variety of bird. To her had fallen the
role of canary; and
her costume of white and yellow satin, together with her
mass of shining
golden hair and pink and white complexion, had
distinguished her in
the eyes of the spectators as a creature of outstanding
charm. Before a
fortnight had passed—so eulogistic were her press notices,
and so unerringly did
the audience single her out for applause—the "Bird
Ballet" was
changed to the "Canary Ballet," and Miss Odell was promoted to
the rank of what
might charitably be called premiere danseuse, at the same
time having a solo
waltz and a song interpolated for the special display of
her charms and
talents.
She had quitted the
Follies at the close of the season, and during her
subsequent
spectacular career in the haunts of Broadway's night life she had
been popularly and
familiarly called the Canary. Thus it happened that when
her dead body was
found, brutally strangled, in her apartment, the crime
immediately became
known, and was always thereafter referred to, as the
Canary murder.
“The Canary” is Margaret
Odell, a minor actress and performer in low-end venues and nightclubs, who
eventually gained great fame within certain Broadway circles. She is well aware
of her role, as well as the judgment passed upon her by the bourgeois circles
for whom she serves as a draw: in her act, she does little more than mimic a
bird and show off her legs. Yet, she harbors the illusion that she can climb
the social ladder and secure a significant place for herself. Her situation is
much like that of a prostitute in a high-end brothel—who might dream of an
impossible love with a handsome client, hoping he will not only use her for his
own pleasure but also introduce her into the "normal" world. Once the
show ends, Margaret Odell finds herself back in the drab reality of everyday
life—a life she escapes only temporarily during her performances, where wealthy
men in spats, top hats, and tailcoats line up to watch her—perhaps swaying on a
swing or perched on a stand—as she, "The Canary," displays her legs.
It is clear, then, that
Margaret Odell—much like any kept woman—seeks someone who can provide her, at
least within her world of glitter and sequins, with a semblance of
respectability and the illusion of having ascended into a society that, in
truth, will never accept her. This is the society of the 1920s—an era when the
Great Depression left tens of thousands destitute, while simultaneously
allowing those who were already wealthy to become even richer. "La
Canarina" has many male friends, and she makes no secret of it: her
companions show her off much like one might display a Ferrari Testarossa today.
Other women—one can easily imagine—either envy her or speak ill of her; yet,
she believes she can leverage these friendships to further her own ambitions—namely,
to advance her career. Having gathered the intimate confessions of the men who
have been between her legs, she one day decides to take a bold step: she
resolves to force the hand of one of her lovers, backing him into a corner. It
is easy to guess—as eventually becomes clear—what "La Canarina"
aspires to: she no longer wishes to be "La Canarina," but rather a
lady of the jet set—to belong to that very world whose "prominent
figures" she has come to know so well. The trouble is, she fails to grasp
one very simple thing: who would ever marry a "Canarina"? But she
remains under an illusion—and, as a result, falls victim to her own dreams.
One fine day, “The Canary” is
found dead—murdered, strangled.
The picture
Van Dine paints of this is chilling:
Her head was turned backward, as
if by force,
over the silken tufted
upholstery; and her hair had come unfastened and lay
beneath her head and over her
bare shoulder like a frozen cataract of liquid
gold. Her face, in violent death,
was distorted and unlovely. Her skin was
discolored; her eyes were
staring; her mouth was open, and her lips were
drawn back. Her neck, on either
side of the thyroid cartilage, showed ugly
dark bruises. She was dressed in
a flimsy evening gown of black Chantilly
lace over cream-colored chiffon,
and across the arm of the davenport had
been thrown an evening cape of
cloth-of-gold trimmed with ermine.
There were evidences of her
ineffectual struggle with the person who had
strangled her. Besides the
disheveled condition of her hair, one of the
shoulder straps of her gown had
been severed, and there was a long rent in
the fine lace across her breast.
A small corsage of artificial orchids had been
torn from her bodice, and lay
crumpled in her lap. One satin slipper had
fallen off, and her right knee
was twisted inward on the seat of the davenport,
as if she had sought to lift
herself out of the suffocating clutches of her
antagonist. Her fingers were
still flexed, no doubt as they had been at the
moment of her capitulation to
death, when she had relinquished her grip upon
the murderer's wrists.
The police investigation at
the scene reveals that certain pieces of jewelry—which, according to the
housekeeper, should have been there—are missing. This leads the authorities to
conclude that the murder was the result of a robbery or a burglary gone wrong
(for Odell).
However, this is the official
police assessment, as voiced by New York District Attorney F.X. Markham, who is
leading the investigation. Philo Vance—a friend of the District Attorney, an
impartial observer, and a man of brilliant intuition—takes a different view.
Once again, he saves the police from embarrassment by exploring a line of
inquiry that no one else had even considered.
Philo Vance represents a
radical evolution of the Sherlock Holmes archetype. While he inherits Holmes’s
keen attention to detail and clues, he does not merely apply them in a rigid,
mechanical fashion. Instead, he insists that any evidence pointing toward a
particular conclusion must also align with a psychological reconstruction
capable of resolving every remaining mystery. To achieve this, Vance—unlike
Holmes—delves into the human soul and mind, with a level of focus that Arthur
Conan Doyle never envisioned for his own detective. Thus, two distinct ideals
are contrasted: the humanistic approach of Philo Vance—deeply attuned to
psychology and the arts born of passion and taste (painting, sculpture,
music)—and the scientific, analytical approach of Sherlock Holmes.
Ultimately, by observing
specific details and looking beyond the mere physical evidence, Philo Vance
provides an explanation that causes the theory of a murder resulting from a
botched robbery to collapse entirely.
Typically, when this novel is
discussed, everyone points to the subtlety of Van Dine’s reasoning regarding
the "locked-room" mystery—a truly imaginative solution. The challenge
lies not so much in how the killer and the witness managed to enter, but in how
they managed to leave; the doorman, upon departing, always secures the small
door leading to the building’s inner courtyard (the rear exit) with an internal
bolt. This ensures that anyone entering the building after his departure must
necessarily pass by the switchboard operator—a detail that is striking, and one
that made a profound impression at the time.
Even more striking to readers
(and critics) was the invention of a method to delay the actual commission of
the crime—making it appear to have occurred later, even though it had already
taken place—by having the victim speak and respond to questions from her
evening companion and the switchboard operator while they stood outside her
door.
While the solution to the
locked-room mystery and the ruse used to misrepresent the timing of the
murder—the very means by which the investigator traps the killer—are routinely
highlighted by anyone analyzing this novel, few, if any, have examined other aspects
of Van Dine’s deductive process.
In my view, another moment
where Van Dine truly impresses the reader is when he has Vance construct a
highly subtle argument based on the position of the victim’s body and the tears
in her clothing. If Margaret Odell had truly been involved in a physical
struggle—during which one would assume she fought back with all her might—why
was a small, innocent bouquet, found in her lap, not cast aside elsewhere? On
the floor, for instance? Furthermore, had that been the case, the neck would
not have been turned backward; instead, the victim would have fallen forward.
Therefore, the crime did not unfold in this manner—a staged scene was created
to lead the investigation astray. The strangulation occurred from behind, at a
moment when the victim did not expect the person behind them to commit such an
act—implying, in other words, that the victim trusted their assailant. But what
about the tears in the clothing? Another part of the ruse: the tears were
inflicted post-mortem to mislead the investigators’ line of reasoning.
A second, highly subtle line
of reasoning concerns the key to the wardrobe: why was it found inside the
wardrobe, when it ought, in the normal course of things, to have been inserted
into the lock from the outside?
There were, therefore, three
people in that room that evening: Margaret Odell and two others—one of whom was
hidden inside the wardrobe. Which of them was the murderer, and which the
witness? Did the murderer also commit a theft later on, or was it the other
person who did the stealing? The presence of these two individuals, and the
distinct roles they played, ties into another point that emerges when Philo
Vance observes that a document case is empty and that a steel jewelry box
appears to have been forced open with a cast-iron fireplace poker. Had a
genuine thief been at work, they surely would have used a more suitable tool to
pry open the lid. This is further corroborated by an expert consulted by Vance,
who confirms that the break-in occurred in two distinct stages: an amateurish
attempt with the poker—which achieved nothing beyond denting the lid—and a
highly professional effort, carried out with a steel instrument, likely a lock
pick. Why, one might ask, would someone bring an inadequate fireplace poker
from the next room when a lock pick was available to do the job?
In short, Vance posits that
the events unfolded in two separate stages, involving two different people.
This establishes a crucial, verified fact: two individuals were present in the
apartment that Saturday evening—likely after the "Canary" had already
been killed. This does not, however, necessarily imply that both were complicit
in the murder. The fact remains that the second unknown visitor will be killed,
and only after his death will Vance—by identifying the stratagem used to delay
the killing—be able to unmask the murderer. In this instance, the stratagem is
directly linked to the murderer’s modus operandi.
In my view, it was precisely
this device—rather than the "locked-room" mystery element—that
accounted for the novel’s success. The reason? The device was tied to an object
that, back in the 1920s, was enjoying a spectacular rise in popularity and
served as a status symbol for affluent families—or, at the very least, those of
the bourgeois class. It was an object associated with music. It was highly
unlikely—if not outright impossible—for a working-class or impoverished family
to cultivate an interest in music; conversely, for families of the upper-middle
class, music functioned as a social marker, a means of distinguishing
themselves from those of a lower standing.
It is no coincidence that
Philo Vance takes an interest in this object—an object dismissed by other
representatives of law enforcement, from the obtuse Sergeant Heath to the
overly conformist District Attorney Markham.
But why does Philo Vance care,
while the others do not? Because Philo Vance is an aesthete; he is drawn to the
arts—pursuits that, for poor Markham, offer no pleasure whatsoever. Vance is a
superior being—a cavalier, a Renaissance prince—who stands above everyone, even
District Attorney Markham. The only person who could truly be considered his
equal is Van Dine himself, who remains concealed behind the persona of the
secretary-squire—the narrator who chronicles Vance’s exploits.
His devotion to the arts
places him on a higher plane than the common folk with whom he interacts.
Philo Vance embodies the
Nietzschean *Übermensch*—a concept with which Willard Huntington Wright was
intimately familiar, having edited the first complete American edition of the
German philosopher’s works. It is precisely these arts or games that he practices
(the game of chess—an instrument of the art of thought and reasoning—will form
the basis of *The Bishop Murder Case*, while poker will play a specific role in
the psychological profiling of the murderer in The Canary Murder Case).
In this novel, I identify four
distinctive characteristics of Philo Vance: deduction (solving the
"locked-room" mystery), psychology (reasoning derived from a game of
poker), curiosity (discovering record packaging in a wastepaper basket), and artistic
sensibility.
Indeed, beyond his irrefutable
demonstration of how one could exit through a door while leaving the bolt
locked from the inside—and beyond his use of psychological insight, gleaned
from a poker game, to suggest a particular individual’s guilt—he would never
have been able to substantiate his accusations had it not been for a purely
chance occurrence.
Can a factor left to chance
truly prevail over Philo Vance’s refined psychological insight and superior
deductive powers? That is the question. The answer is no.
And yet, in this instance, one
might argue that his superiority is indeed affirmed. I would emphasize,
however, that Philo Vance’s personality is defined by a combination of various
factors—the four aforementioned characteristics—among which his artistic
sensibility carries significant weight; in this specific case, it proves
absolutely decisive. While this artistic sensibility appears only fleetingly
throughout the novel—as if deliberately keeping a low profile to avoid being
labeled as a defining trait—it ultimately plays a pivotal role in the
conclusion.
What is the point of all this?
Simply to assert that in this novel—a detail culpably overlooked by many
critics—the most crucial factor in establishing the guilt of a specific
individual, relative to others, is none other than Philo Vance’s artistic sensibility.
This entails a literary sensibility—evidenced by a wealth of quotations from
Latin, French, and German works—as well as a sensitivity toward the visual
arts, sculpture, and other types of artistic artifacts, such as carpets and
porcelain. And, perhaps even more—or at least more overtly—in this novel,
Vance’s artistic sensibility manifests as a musical one.
Throughout the investigation, one can discern
the significance of Vance’s artistic sensibilities—from his observations on the
absurdity of using parchment to fashion a wastepaper basket, to his remarks on
the craftsmanship of the rugs, and finally, his assessments concerning music.
Philo Vance finds himself in the
"Canary’s" apartment, searching for something—though he does not yet
know what. He believes he knows the identity of the murderer—he is, in fact,
certain of it—having played poker with the men who feature in this drama: the
Canary’s lovers. Yet, knowing the culprit’s identity is not enough; at that
moment, he has no way to prove the individual’s guilt. A seemingly irrefutable
fact stands in his way: a person—someone outside the circle of suspects—was
with the murderer at a critical time and would, in all good faith, swear under
torture that the killer was in their company. This is why Vance, accompanied by
Markham, ends up lingering at the victim’s home—and it is precisely here that
the pieces of the puzzle fall into place for him.
Among all his various tastes, Vance’s musical
knowledge proves decisive; had he not been well-versed in classical music, the
solution would have eluded him. Conversely, it is worth noting that had the
murderer followed a different line of reasoning, Vance would surely have been
unable to establish his guilt.
Thus, another element enters the equation of
accountability: Fate—from which there is no escape.
1. It is Fate that dictates the murderer’s decision to toss a
package into a wastebasket; yet, had it been an ordinary bin, Vance would have
taken no notice of it—but he observes that it is made of parchment. To anyone
else, this detail would mean nothing, but to a man like him—possessing an
innate sensitivity toward all that is beautiful and refined, in an aesthetic
sense—such a parchment wastebasket is an affront. Consequently, he decides to
look inside, where he discovers a crumpled sheet of wrapping paper and a large,
square, brown parcel.
2. Were Vance not a music enthusiast—did he not frequent
theaters or attend concerts—he would never have deduced that the parcel
contained phonograph records. At this juncture, the specter of music emerges:
it is the musical inclinations and tastes of both the murderer and the
detective that ultimately hold the key to solving the enigma.
Vance asks Markham where the
gramophone is (because if there's a record, there must be a
gramophone ). Knowing the
answer, he looks for it. The gramophone is in the antechamber;
on top of it is a small rug
topped with a flowerpot.
3. If Vance
hadn't been an art expert, he would never have been interested in that rug. But
it's also worth noting that if the murderer hadn't placed a rug and a flowerpot
to prevent anyone from
looking
into the gramophone, Vance's attention probably wouldn't have been caught. He
notes, in fact, that it is “Anatolian—probably called a
Caesarian for sale purposes. Not very valuable—too much on the Oushak type”.
Disgusted by an exterior devoid of any artistic
merit and dictated solely by the law of appearances, Vance wonders what kind of
music the Canary might have listened to:
“Wonder what the lady's taste
in music was. Victor Herbert, doubtless”.
Who was Victor Herbert at that
time? A composer and a driving force in the musical life of New York, in
particular; an author of operettas as well as well-known pieces—such as
"Serenades of All Nations," which featured singing and dancing—his work
represented an alternative to "serious" music. At this juncture, the
hand of Fate intervenes, setting the murderer’s poor choice (but why poor,
exactly?) against Vance’s own musical curiosity: "My word! The Andante from Beethoven's C-Minor
Symphony!" he exclaimed cheerfully. “You know the movement, of course,
Markham. The most perfect Andante ever written." He wound up the machine.
"I think a little music might clear the atmosphere and volatilize our
perturbation, what?”
Vance’s surprise is all the more striking given
that, up to this point, he has found the "Canary’s" aesthetic
sensibilities to be utterly objectionable; thus, Odell’s musical
taste—Beethoven—comes as a shock to him... a positive one. And so, he decides
to listen to the record.
As it turns
out, the Canary’s musical tastes were likely those originally surmised by
Vance. It was not she who put on the record labeled "Beethoven," but
rather her murderer. Yet, the killer could never have foreseen that—in the
misfortune of having met the Canary, becoming her accompanist and lover, and
subsequently being blackmailed—he would suffer a further stroke of bad luck:
making a choice that, under ordinary circumstances, would have been a perfectly
happy one. His misfortune lay in crossing paths with someone like Vance—a
refined aesthete and true connoisseur of art and music. Had anyone else been
accompanying Markham—someone with more conventional aesthetic tastes—it is
almost certain that, in 99% of cases, they would never have chosen to listen to
Beethoven. The murderer’s ill fortune, therefore, was to be pitted against a
man who happened to be drawn to those very same musical preferences.
This is
why, in the resolution of The Canary
Murder Case, Vance’s inclination toward artistic—and, above all,
musical—sensibility plays a fundamental role. A role, as we have seen, that is
inextricably linked to the element of chance, preordained by Fate.
Fate—the
force to which both men and gods are subject; Fate—which, like an invisible yet
inexorable mechanism, binds individuals to their actions; Fate, ultimately, as
the quintessential driving force of great Greek tragedy. The story of the Canary is not a grand tragedy, but a minor
one—yet a tragedy nonetheless, not merely a drama. A drama allows for an
outcome—be it positive or negative—whereas a tragedy offers no positive
resolution; it is invariably negative, for the innocent and the guilty alike.
Here, the guilty and the innocent perish in the very same way: is Odell the
innocent one and X the guilty party? Or is it the other way around? It is
neither: in this novel, the guilty and the innocent are not clearly demarcated;
rather, they blur into one another.
As players
in a tragedy, the characters often move as if enthralled by a will that
transcends them—a force from which there is no escape.
To my mind,
Fate is also linked to the musical reference explicitly mentioned on the record
label: the Andante in C minor from Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony. The key of C
minor—inherently somber and frequently employed in Requiems (alongside the more
common D minor)—becomes, in Beethoven’s hands, the key of the hero. Moreover,
this symphony is often described as the one in which "Fate knocks at the
door"—another allusion to Fate, to Destiny, to something on the verge of
coming to pass.
At the end
of the novel the murderer himself will admit that “It occurred to me that if anyone should, by any chance, open the
phonograph before I could return and destroy the record, he wouldn't be as
likely to want to hear the classics as he would a more popular selection."
"And one who detests popular
music had to find it! I fear, Mr.****, that an unkind fate sat in at your
game."
"Yes. . . . If I were
religiously inclined, I might talk poppycock about
retribution and divine
punishment.”
There are,
however, other musical references scattered here and there.
For one,
there is an allusion to Mozart. In Chapter VII, we read that Odell’s maid is
formally questioned by Markham in the presence of Vance; she speaks of a
certain man—a former lover of Odell’s—who “He wore his hair smoothed down, Spively continued, "and you could see it was kind of long; but
it was cut in the latest style. And he had a small waxed moustache; and there
was a big carnation in the lapel of his coat, and he had on chamois gloves. . .
.”. Shortly
thereafter, while discussing this with Markham, Vance uses an Italian adjective
“amoroso”—which anyone with a certain degree of culture, especially in
music, would immediately associate with Mozart. Vance remarks: “Nearly every modern Delilah has an avaricious amoroso.”
To me, the adjective “amoroso”immediately
brings to mind an aria from Mozart’s opera Le Nozze di Figaro—the piece
that concludes the first act—which begins: “Non più andrai, farfallone
amoroso, notte e giorno d’intorno girando; delle belle turbando il riposo,
Narcisetto, Adoncino d’amor.” It is almost certain that Vance intends to evoke this Mozartian “farfallone”
even though he elsewhere uses the term “gigolo”—a fitting choice, given
that the man in question would solicit money from Odell (though he did not
blackmail her).
There are,
however, other musical references scattered here and there.
For one,
there is an allusion to Mozart. In Chapter VII, we read that Odell’s maid is
formally questioned by Markham in the presence of Vance. She speaks of a
certain man—a former lover of Odell’s—who dressed in the latest fashion,
visited her often, and always managed to extract money from her. Shortly
thereafter, while discussing this with Markham, Vance uses an Italian adjective
(the term appears in Italian in the original text)—a rather unusual word that
anyone with a certain level of culture, including musical knowledge, would
immediately associate with Mozart. Vance remarks: “...Almost every modern-day
Delilah has a greedy “amoroso”...” .
To me, the
adjective “amoroso” immediately brings to mind an aria from Mozart’s opera Le
Nozze di Figaro, which concludes the first act and begins with the lines: “Non
più andrai, farfallone amoroso, notte e giorno d’intorno girando; delle belle
turbando il riposo Narcisetto, Adoncino d’amor.” Vance is almost certainly
making an implicit reference to this Mozartian “farfallone” (philanderer)—even
though he elsewhere uses the term “gigolo”—in light of the fact that the man in
question would ask Odell for money (though he was not blackmailing her).
Hidden
within that same sentence, there may be yet another musical reference: Vance
associates the name “Delilah” with Odell. We all know that Delilah was a
Philistine—a sort of Mata Hari of her day—who used her beauty to make Samson
fall in love with her. However, this reference might also allude to Camille
Saint-Saëns’s opera Samson et Dalila, which was performed at the
Metropolitan Opera in New York during the 1915–16 season, featuring Margarete
Matzenauer as Delilah and Enrico Caruso as Samson.
But the
musical references do not end there.
First,
there is a piece for solo piano. Before Vance turns his attention to the
wastepaper basket, he notices a piano; he sits down and plays the opening of
Brahms’s Capriccio No. 1.
Capriccio
No. 1 is the
first of eight pieces in Op. 76. It is in F-sharp minor—a key one might
describe as "painful," perhaps even "harrowing." The sharp
seems to intensify the sorrow inherent in F minor, pushing it to a point of no
return. One could even argue that, for some, F-sharp minor is the key of
tragedy, though that might be reading too much into it. Let us, therefore,
stick to the piece itself. It is a work built on arpeggios and is quite
technically demanding. What does this tell us? It suggests that Vance is not
merely an amateur with a taste for beautiful things, nor just a learned
dilettante, but a sophisticated professional: he knows how to play the
piano—and, what’s more, he plays a difficult piece. In other words, even in the
case of music—much like painting, sculpture, or his expertise in areas such as
porcelain and carpets—Philo Vance’s engagement is never merely superficial;
rather, it is always marked by a level of knowledge that distinguishes him not
only from the uneducated masses but also from other aesthetes like himself.
The second
musical reference concerns something that struck me as glaringly obvious—yet
which I failed to notice years ago when I first read the novel: the—surely
intentional—resemblance between Margaret Odell, a rapidly rising dancer, and
the alter ego of Princess Odette from the famous ballet set to Tchaikovsky’s
music: Odile, the Black Swan, daughter of the sorcerer Rothbart, who seeks to
replace Odette and steal the love of Prince Derek.
Odile and
Odell are not merely similar in name; they are also linked by their
associations with birds—a swan and a canary, respectively. Just as the Black
Swan uses magic to make Derek perceive her as Odette—with evil disguising
itself as good—Odell, who might appear as pure as her own singing voice,
actually possesses a soul as black as sin.
Both Odile
and Odell can thus be related to Odette, forming an ideal triad:
Odile–Odell–Odette.
Both Odile
and Odell aspire to identify with Odette. While we have already touched upon
Odile’s identification, there is also a hidden one at play with Odell: the
"Odette" that Odell embodies is a version of herself transformed into
a positive figure—one accepted and recognized by society.
A reflection and an insight: applying the Mimetic Theory of Desire to "The Canary Murder Case"
When
considering these three characters—both individually and in terms of their
mutual relationships—one can apply René Girard’s "Theory of Mimetic Desire,"
(from Mensonge romantique et verité Romanesque,
1961) particularly
when examining the specific roles of “Subject, Object, and Mediator”.
Girard
identified a common thread throughout literature: desire. Desire is never a
direct expression of the subject; rather, it is a reflection of someone else’s
desire for a particular object. In its manifestation, two alternative scenarios
emerge: when the object of desire is distant, the subject (who desires what the
mediator desires) and the mediator can coexist peacefully; conversely, when the
object of desire is close—situated on the same plane as both parties—conflict
arises.
Thus, we
can apply the Theory of Mimetic Desire to the novel in question.
First, let
us examine the triad: Odette is the desired object—sought by Odile, who aspires
to identify with her in order to steal Derek’s love, and also, metaphorically,
by Odell, who wishes to transform from a dull "Canary" into a Swan
and possess the love of a prince, just as Odette does. In this instance, we
have "external mediation": Odell desires to be Odette, with Odile
acting as the mediator of this desire—Odile herself aspiring to transform into
Odette. Both the mediator and the subject are, in a sense, incomplete; as such,
they strive to become the object of desire through deception (Odile transforms
into Odette via an illusion, while Odell seeks to become Odette through
blackmail). Because Odette—as an object of desire—remains distant, the two characters
do not come into conflict on an ideal plane.
However, if
we examine these two individual cases, the mediation becomes even more
apparent:
In
Tchaikovsky’s work, for instance, the desiring subject is Odile, the desired
object is Prince Derek, and the mediator of this desire is Odette. According to
René Girard, this would constitute what is known as “internal mediation”—a
dynamic characterized by an escalating conflict that grows increasingly violent
and paroxysmal as the two spheres—the two desires directed toward the same
object—come into contact. A similar characterization can be found in Van Dine’s
novel, specifically in the relationship between Margaret Odell and her object
of desire. Here, too, “internal mediation” is at play: Margaret Odell (the
subject) craves a particular object—namely, economic and social stability—which
is also the object sought by the mediator, “X.” The subject (Odell) and the
mediator (“X”) find themselves in conflict over this object; the intensity of
this clash is directly proportional to the strength of the subject’s (Odell’s)
desire to possess it. Thus, the aspiration for a new social status collides
with the mediator’s (“X’s”) determination to preserve the stability of the
existing order—an order bound up with “X’s” own familial ties. The conflict is
all the more profound and intractable because, in order to break down “X’s”
defenses, blackmail is employed.
Odile and
Odell are linked by yet another connection: both are dancers, though their
relationship to dance is antithetical. For the former, Odile, dance emerges
from tragedy; for the latter, Odell, tragedy emerges from dance—specifically
from the relationships she forged through her life as a dancer. Also linked to
music is the use of the gramophone—an object that, until then, had been
associated with a frivolous, salon-dwelling world, one that had emerged from
the First World War yet had not yet encountered the Great Depression of 1929.
Up to that point, no one had ever considered using it for any purpose other
than playing music; but after Van Dine, things changed…
First, I
would like to mention Agatha Christie and her 1939 novel And Then There Were
None. Here, the mechanism underlying the use of the gramophone is reversed.
In Van Dine’s work, the gramophone is used to create an illusion—specifically,
to convince the hotel porter that "the Canary" was still alive at a
certain hour, when, in fact, she was already dead (a device one might
colorfully describe as "a voice from beyond the grave"), in Agatha
Christie’s And Then There Were None, however, the voice of Mr. Owen (the
host)—recorded on a disc and amplified by a gramophone—serves the opposite
purpose: it is intended to convince the ten people present that the speaker is
not physically among them, when in reality, he is.
While
Christie adopts this Van Dine device and adapts it to her own ends, there is an
earlier instance—predating Christie’s novel—in which the "gramophone
illusion" is recreated using a device that had largely supplanted the
gramophone by the 1930s: the radio. Clayton Rawson employs this to create a
different kind of illusion in his 1938 novel Death from a Top Hat. Even
earlier, in 1930, another novel—The Invisible Host by Bristow &
Manning—utilized the radio as a device, though in this case, it was linked to
concealed gramophones.
Finally,
Vance occasionally displays his erudition. One such instance occurs in Chapter
VIII, as Vance and Markham discuss footprints left in the snow: Grau, teurer
Freund, ist alle Theorie, Philo Vance declares—a line taken from one of the
most famous passages in Goethe’s “Faust”. But what Vance quotes is only
half of it. The full passage would be: “Grau, teurer Freund, ist alle
Theorie, und grün des Lebens goldner Baum”—literally: “Dear friend, all
theory is gray, and green is the golden tree of life.” Vance, however,
cites only the first part, adapting it to the conversation he is having with
Markham—a discussion centered on the absence of footprints in the snow and the
lack of any account of who might have left them; in other words, the fact that
Markham possesses neither direct nor circumstantial evidence (=the theory is
gray).
This is not
the only such passage; there are several others.
For
example, at one point in Chapter 10, it says: “Perhaps so. He might well be a
modern Cayley Drummle.” Who is Cayley Drummle? One
would need to be familiar with Arthur Wing Pinero’s play The Second Mrs.
Tanqueray to know, but neither Van Dine nor the translators explain it. Van
Dine omits the explanation because the meaning of his remark is clear enough
within the context of his conversation with Markham; furthermore, if his
references weren’t somewhat cryptic, one couldn’t truly appreciate the extent
of Van Dine’s encyclopedic erudition. As for the translators, they likely leave
the mystery unsolved either because they don’t know the answer themselves or
because they see no reason to take on the extra, uncompensated burden of
research.
The point,
however, is that the average reader of Van Dine—confronted with these
digressions, learned allusions, and quotations—cannot reasonably be expected to
possess the same encyclopedic knowledge as Van Dine or his character, Philo
Vance. Consequently, either the translator must be diligent enough to do the
necessary research, or the reader must either undertake that research to fully
grasp what Van Dine is saying—or simply skip over these awkward references
entirely.
This serves
to highlight the fact that, contrary to popular belief, S.S. Van Dine’s
detective novels are not at all easy to read; quite the opposite!
“It's latish, I'll admit, but
why not, as Pittacus advised, seize time by the
forelock?
Who lets slip fortune, her shall
never find:
Occasion once past by, is a bald
behind.'
But the elder Cato anticipated
Cowley. In his 'Disticha de Moribus' he
wrote: Fronte capillata.
Come!" pleaded Markham,
rising. "Anything to dam this flow of erudition.”
We
understand that the distich attributed to Pittacus must be linked to Cowley.
But who is this man—as Don Abbondio might ask? No one mentions that he is one
of the greatest English poets of the seventeenth century.
Fortunately,
Chapter 10 concludes with Cato the Elder—or at least the source of the
reference is cited: The Distichs (though some contemporary critics
question whether Cato the Elder is truly the author).
Thus, we
learn that Vance—wishing to seize the favorable opportunity, the opportune
moment—cites neither Lorenzo the Magnificent nor Horace (for the “favorable
opportunity” or “opportune moment” associated with Fortuna is not quite
the same as the Carpe Diem found in those two authors), but rather
Abraham Cowley and Marcus Porcius Cato. The reference to Cowley stems directly
from the Catonian distich: “Rem, tibi quam noris aptam, dimittere noli:
Fronte capillata, post est Occasio calva” (“Do not let go of what you know
to be good for you; Occasio [Opportunity] has hair on her forehead, but is
bald at the back”—Distichs, Book 1, 2.26).
Why? Van
Dine does not explain this either. He expects his reader to know or to surmise
it: the point is that the Catonian distich is to be understood in relation to
the Roman conception of the Goddess Fortuna—the hair on the forehead and the
bald nape of the neck signify not only youth and old age, but also good and bad
fortune. However, “occasione=occasio” is expressed using a Latin
noun—capitalized—signifying a proper name: it refers to a goddess, Occasio,
who is linked to the Greek Kairos (καιρός), a minor deity of time representing “the opportune
moment.”
A brief,
separate discussion is warranted for the following passage:
“Perhaps
because he was in love with her,’ Markham smiled.
‘A bit like
Abra, eh?…
Abra was
ready before I even called her:
Abra came,
though it was another I was calling.”
Van
Dine—through his character Vance—offers no explanation for this inserted
couplet.
The source is : “Solomon
on the Vanity of the World”, Book II, by Matthew Prior—a great English poet
who lived at the turn of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, just
preceding Alexander Pope.
Philo Vance, then, stands
as a paragon of elegance, artistic sensibility, musical expertise, and literary
knowledge—all these qualities distilled into a single term: erudition. And in
this novel (or rather, throughout the series) by S.S. Van Dine, such erudition
is present in abundance. It can be entertaining and intriguing, yet at times,
it may also prove irritating.
Indeed, as we find
ourselves immersed in the adventures of Philo Vance, might we not echo the very
sentiment expressed by the character speaking to him?
“Come!" pleaded Markham,
rising. "Anything to dam this flow of erudition.”
Thus ends the tenth
chapter of the novel, and with it my analysis—which I hope will be well
received.
Pietro De Palma